Explore Paynes Bay
Discover 52 top-rated accommodations and travel hubs.
52≤ 2 miles
52≤ 5 miles
52≤ 10 miles
Browse by Category
Featured Stays
Jubilance Beach Cottage Sandy Lane
0.3 mi from centerAll
Highway 1B Sandy Lane
View DetailsVilla Point of View
0.3 mi from centerThreeStar
Sandy Lane Estate St James
View DetailsHorizons by Altman
0.3 mi from centerFourStar
Sandy Lane Paynes Bay
View DetailsVilla Horizons
0.4 mi from centerThreeStar
South Road Sandy Lane
View DetailsMahogany Bay by Blue Sky Luxury
0.4 mi from centerFourStar
Mahogany Bay
View DetailsVillas & Suites at Beach View
0.4 mi from centerFourStar
Parish Of St. James
View DetailsVilla Casablanca
0.4 mi from centerThreeStar
Villa Casablanca
View DetailsMoon Dance by Altman
0.4 mi from centerFourStar
South Road Sandy Lane 10000 St James
View DetailsBeach View Hotel
0.4 mi from centerFourStar
Paynes Bay 24009 St. James
View DetailsBeach View 208 by Altman
0.4 mi from centerFourStar
Paynes Bay
View DetailsSandy Bliss Condominiums
0.4 mi from centerThreeStar
Sandy Lane Golf Links Drive Parish of St. James Golf Links DriveParish of St. JamesBB24016 Paynes Bay
View DetailsSandy Cove 204
0.5 mi from centerFiveStar
Sandy Cove 204
View DetailsShowing page 4 of 5 • 52 hotels
Frequently Asked Questions about Paynes Bay
Is Paynes Bay a good destination for luxury travel?
Yes! Approximately 62% of our listed accommodations in Paynes Bay are 4-star or 5-star properties, making it highly suitable for luxury stays.